Signals from a World in Flux: The Politics of Emotion, the Greening of the City, and the Performance of Identity
From the Open Access Blog.
Navigating the Currents: Reflections on Adaptation and Resilience
The collection of newsletter snippets from Monocle, Bloomberg, Semafor, ArtNews and the Economist from July 7-13, 2025, paints a portrait of a world grappling with a series of profound, interlocking transformations. These dispatches, though varied in subject—from the tears of a politician to the algorithmic logic of AI—collectively illuminate a global society caught between the centrifugal forces of fragmentation and the centripetal search for new forms of resilience, community, and meaning. The articles reveal deep anxieties about political legitimacy, environmental stability, economic coherence, and cultural identity. By examining these fragments through the lenses of political philosophy, sociology, economic theory, and cultural studies, we can discern the contours of a world system under immense strain, where old certainties are dissolving and new paradigms are struggling to be born.
The snippets from last week’s newsletters, thus, paint a vivid tableau of our fractured yet interlinked world—one in which emotion, identity, mobility, urban nature and design converge to shape contemporary life. At the heart of these dispatches lies a tension between the human and the systemic: public figures chide tears as market-moving weaknesses even as athletes and executives deploy them as endearing signals of authenticity; city dwellers reclaim polluted waterways and rooftops as shared commons; and corporations, from airlines to fashion houses, recalibrate their visual identities to speak both to heritage and to a global clientele.
In a world marked by rapid change and uncertainty, the newsletter snippets also offer a kaleidoscope of human adaptation. From the tearful vulnerability of political leaders to the innovative rebranding of fashion houses, from the revival of urban waterways to the resilience of communities facing environmental disasters, these stories reflect a global landscape in flux. Yet, amidst the turbulence, there are threads of continuity, echoes of history, and the persistent human drive to create meaning and connection. This commentary weaves these threads together, drawing on scholarly works, literature, and philosophical ideas to illuminate the cultural, economic, policy, and social implications of these snapshots from our changing world.
The newsletter snippets, therefore, present a kaleidoscope of contemporary global developments. These brief yet evocative dispatches—from a British politician’s tears to urban beekeeping in Tokyo—offer a window into a world grappling with change, identity, and resilience. The reflections aim to illuminate the multifaceted implications of these developments, revealing both their particularity and their resonance with universal themes.
Political Adaptation: Emotion in Leadership
The public display of emotion by Rachel Reeves, the UK’s chancellor, challenges long-held cultural norms about leadership and stoicism. In ancient Rome, leaders like Marcus Aurelius espoused the virtues of emotional control, as he wrote in his Meditations: “If you are distressed by anything external, the pain is not due to the thing itself, but to your estimate of it; and this you have the power to revoke at any moment” (Aurelius, 167 A.C.E./2002, p. 45). Yet, in the modern era, there is a growing recognition of the value of emotional intelligence in leadership. Daniel Goleman’s seminal work argues that empathy and self-awareness are critical for effective governance (Goleman, 1995). Reeves’ tears, whether prompted by personal matters or political pressures, humanize her in a way that contrasts sharply with the “Iron Lady” archetype of predecessors like Theresa May. This shift reflects a broader cultural reevaluation of strength in leadership, moving from stoic detachment toward authenticity—a tension mirrored in literature, such as in Shakespeare’s King Lear, where the king’s vulnerability exposes both his humanity and his frailty (Shakespeare, 1606/2005).
Economically, Reeves’ emotional moment rattled markets, suggesting that perceptions of political stability influence financial systems. Socially, it raises questions about gendered expectations: while sports stars are lauded for tears, politicians face scrutiny, revealing persistent cultural double standards. This resonates with Judith Butler’s exploration of gender performativity, where societal norms dictate acceptable emotional expressions (Butler, 1990).
The opinion piece on UK Chancellor Rachel Reeves’s public display of tears serves as a potent entry point into the contemporary politics of emotion and leadership. The immediate, and largely negative, media reaction highlights a persistent, gendered expectation for leaders to embody an impassive, "Teflon" stoicism. This ideal, however, runs counter to a more nuanced understanding of the role of emotion in public life. Philosopher Martha C. Nussbaum (2013) argues that emotions are not merely irrational impulses but are "suffused with intelligence and discernment," and that a healthy polity requires leaders capable of demonstrating appropriate emotional responses like compassion and even grief. The scorn directed at Reeves, and previously at Theresa May, suggests a public sphere that simultaneously craves authenticity while punishing perceived vulnerability in its leaders, especially women.
Take, for example, the coverage of UK chancellor Rachel Reeves’s tearful moment in the Commons and its reverberations across international media. As Ed Stocker observes, Reeves’s display “proved that politicians are fallible and human,” a counterpoint to the “Teflon Men and Iron Ladies” of recent decades—figures who are deemed too wooden if they remain stoic or too emotional if they weep. This double bind speaks to Sara Ahmed’s insight that emotions are not merely private states but cultural practices that circulate power: tears become both a performative act and a site of political contestation, where empathy and professionalism are pitted against each other (Ahmed, 2004).
Ed Stocker’s reflection on Rachel Reeves’s public display of emotion in Westminster invites us to reconsider the performative boundaries of political leadership and the gendered expectations that underpin them. Stocker notes that Reeves’s tears were “proof that politicians are fallible and human” at a moment when “politicians often seem out of touch” (Stocker, 2025, p. 1) . This vulnerability contrasts sharply with the “Teflon Men and Iron Ladies” archetypes that modern electorates both demand and deride. From a cultural studies perspective, Judith Butler’s notion of gender performativity helps us see how Reeves’s tears subvert hegemonic scripts of stoicism in political discourse (Butler, 1990). Economically, we might recall Amartya Sen’s capabilities approach: by displaying emotion, Reeves reclaims an authenticity that expands the public’s capability to engage empathetically with policy debates (Sen, 1999). Socially, this episode resonates with Arlie Hochschild’s “emotional labor” thesis, reminding us that the management of feeling in public office carries its own burdens and expectations (Hochschild, 1983).
Politics: The Human Face of Power
The snippet “For crying out loud: Tears aren’t the weakness that many would have you believe” examines UK Chancellor Rachel Reeves’ public tears, sparking a discourse on emotion in politics. Culturally, this event challenges the stoic archetype of leadership, particularly for women, who navigate a gendered tightrope between authenticity and professionalism. Reeves’ vulnerability contrasts with the “Iron Lady” trope epitomized by Margaret Thatcher, suggesting a shift toward a more humanized political ethos. Economically, her tears—linked by media to a faltering Labour policy—rattled markets, underscoring the fragility of financial stability tied to political perception (Stocker, 2025). Policy-wise, the incident reflects the Labour Party’s struggle with welfare reform, hinting at internal disarray and public accountability pressures.
This resonates with Arlie Hochschild’s The Managed Heart (1983), which introduces “emotional labor” as the effort to align personal feelings with societal expectations. Reeves’ tears reveal the strain of this labor in the political sphere, where leaders must perform resilience while bearing personal and public burdens (Hochschild, 1983). Literarily, it echoes Virginia Woolf’s A Room of One’s Own (1929), where she critiques the constraints on women’s public expression: “All the conditions of her life, all her own instincts, were hostile to the state of mind which is needed to set free whatever is in the brain” (Woolf, 1929, p. 51). Philosophically, Nietzsche’s concept of the “Übermensch” in Thus Spoke Zarathustra(1883-1885)—an ideal of self-overcoming—might frame Reeves’ display as a rejection of imposed stoicism, embracing fallibility as strength.
The Performance of Power and the Politics of Emotion
Natalie Theodosi’s account of Michael Rider’s debut at Celine speaks to brand evolution in the luxury industry. Rider’s nods to Céline’s founding ethos of “couture sportswear” (Theodosi, 2025, p. 5) recall Walter Benjamin’s notion of aura: by revering the “original” vision of Céline Vipiana even as he injects fresh creativity, Rider sustains the brand’s aura while reauthorizing its contemporary relevance (Benjamin, 1936/1968). Economically, the focus on heritage echoes David A. Hanks’s analysis of “cultural capital” as a driver of luxury market differentiation (Hanks, 2002).
This tension is mirrored in the international reception of a French mural depicting the Statue of Liberty hiding her face in shame. The statue, a potent symbol of American ideals, is re-contextualized as a performer of national emotion—in this case, embarrassment over the state of its own professed values. The polarized reactions it provokes underscore a world where national symbols are no longer stable signifiers but are actively contested sites of meaning, reflecting deep divisions within and outside the nation-state. This act of artistic commentary functions as a form of what political scientist James C. Scott (1990) might call an "infrapolitical" act—a subtle, symbolic challenge to the dominant narrative of American exceptionalism, made visible on the global stage.
Economically, these rebrands bolster market competitiveness, as brands leverage cultural narratives to maintain relevance. Socially, they reflect a globalized world where identity is renegotiated through consumption, echoing Arjun Appadurai’s idea of cultural flows in Modernity at Large, where local traditions intersect with global influences (Appadurai, 1996). Philosophically, this tension between heritage and innovation recalls T.S. Eliot’s “Tradition and the Individual Talent,” where he suggests that “the past should be altered by the present as much as the present is directed by the past” (Eliot, 1919/1997, p. 43).
Culture: Fashion as Identity and Continuity
In “Celine presents a fresh vision under its new creative director, Michael Rider,” the fashion house’s rebrand under Rider reflects cultural continuity and innovation. Culturally, Rider’s nod to Celine’s heritage—merging founder Céline Vipiana’s sportswear flair with predecessors’ signatures—embodies a dialogue between past and present, a hallmark of French identity in luxury. Economically, this strategic rebrand aims to sustain profitability in a competitive market, with Rider’s focus on wearable elegance signaling a consumer-centric shift (Theodosi, 2025). Socially, the understated presentation—no gimmicks, just architecture and rain—suggests a cultural elite prioritizing substance over spectacle.
Joanne Entwistle’s The Fashioned Body (2000) provides a lens here, arguing that fashion constructs identity: “Dress is a basic fact of social life… a means by which individuals negotiate their presence in the world” (Entwistle, 2000, p. 6). Rider’s collection negotiates Celine’s legacy with modernity, mirroring Roland Barthes’ The Fashion System (1967), where clothing is a semiotic system reflecting cultural values. In literature, Marcel Proust’s In Search of Lost Time (1913-1927) captures this temporal interplay, as characters’ attire signifies both personal memory and societal shifts: “The clothes she wore… were a kind of bridge between the present and the past” (Proust, 1913-1927/1992, p. 342). Philosophically, Heidegger’s Being and Time (1927) and its focus on “being-in-the-world” suggest that Rider’s designs anchor wearers in a historical continuum, affirming identity through material culture.
Cultural Adaptation: Branding and Identity
In aviation and fashion, brands navigate the balance between tradition and innovation. All Nippon Airways’ (ANA) uniform redesign for its 75th anniversary and Celine’s fresh vision under Michael Rider are not mere aesthetic shifts but strategic moves to reinforce identity in a globalized market. Pierre Bourdieu’s concept of cultural capital illuminates this, positing that taste and style signify social distinction (Bourdieu, 1984). ANA’s collaboration with designers like Naoki Takizawa reflects Japan’s cultural emphasis on precision and aesthetics, while Celine’s nod to its heritage aligns with what fashion scholar Yuniya Kawamura calls the “evolutionary continuity” essential for luxury brands (Kawamura, 2005, p. 87). Similarly, Speedo’s “Speedo Summer” taps into a rebellious yet performance-driven identity, adapting to shifting consumer preferences.
Yet authenticity is no longer an exclusively political currency. In the corporate sphere, All Nippon Airways’s forthcoming uniform redesign under Naoki Takizawa and Satoshi Kuwata exemplifies how visual culture can be leveraged to bolster employee morale, reaffirm brand heritage and project global ambition. Likewise, Celine’s new creative director Michael Rider has adopted a subtler rebadging strategy—honoring Phoebe Philo’s minimalist legacy while weaving in fresh “couture sportswear” references and experiential touches like floral invitations. Such gestures resonate with Pierre Bourdieu’s notion of “symbolic capital,” where stylistic choices both signal and consolidate a brand’s membership in an exclusive cultural field (Bourdieu, 1984).
Fiona Wilson’s report on All Nippon Airways’s uniform redesign for its 75th anniversary highlights the interplay between corporate branding, national identity, and employee morale. Wilson describes how designer Naoki Takizawa and Adidas will collaborate “to create a design that is functional and appropriate for the nature of the work, that supports employee morale and will be globally recognised” (Wilson, 2025, p. 2) . Here, Pierre Bourdieu’s theory of habitus and distinction is instructive: uniforms not only signal class and taste but also constitute embodied capital that shapes social interactions onboard and beyond (Bourdieu, 1984). Policy-wise, the investment of €1.4 billion in the Seine’s clean-up—another Dutch-style public-works marvel—prefigures a shift toward a “green Keynesianism” that Peter Hall (1993) argued is necessary for sustainable urban futures.
The Urban Palimpsest: Greening, Resilience, and the Remaking of Public Space
A powerful counter-narrative to political fragmentation emerges from the articles on urbanism. The reopening of the Seine for swimming, the proliferation of "sky gardens" in Singapore and Milan, and the success of urban beekeeping in Tokyo all point to a concerted effort to reimagine the city as a site of resilience, biodiversity, and human connection. These initiatives represent a practical application of the "biophilia hypothesis," popularized by biologist E. O. Wilson (who is cited in the newsletter), which posits an innate human tendency to seek connections with nature (Wilson, 1984).
The €1.4 billion cleanup of the Seine is more than an infrastructure project; it is a symbolic reclamation of the urban commons, turning a polluted industrial artery back into a space for public leisure and relief from climate-change-induced heatwaves. This recalls the urban philosophy of Jane Jacobs (1961), who championed the vitality of mixed-use, pedestrian-oriented public spaces as the lifeblood of a healthy city. Similarly, the rise of sky gardens and urban apiaries represents a conscious effort to re-weave nature into the dense fabric of the built environment, tackling the urban heat island effect while fostering community and a tangible connection to the non-human world. These projects are not mere amenities but are crucial experiments in climate adaptation and the creation of more livable, sustainable urban futures. The rebuilding of the Pacific Palisades with its "Case Study 2.0" initiative further highlights this theme of resilience, looking to architectural history not for nostalgia, but for a template to rebuild a community shattered by the increasingly frequent devastation of wildfires.
Not all reinventions unfold behind boardroom doors. In Paris, the reopening of the Seine to public bathing reflects a civic-minded policy gambit that melds urban design with climate adaptation. After investing €1.4 billion to remediate water quality, the city has reclaimed a once-neglected resource to mitigate heatwaves and cultivate new forms of social life along its banks. Scholars of urban resilience note that such “blue-green” infrastructure can reduce mortality during extreme weather events and foster a sense of collective stewardship—an essential component of climate justice in historically underprivileged neighborhoods (Meerow & Newell, 2017).
Similarly, Tokyo’s rooftop apiaries—ten years in the making via the Marunouchi Honey Project—demonstrate how urban nature initiatives can simultaneously enhance biodiversity, promote community building and reconnect citizens to the more-than-human world. However, urban beekeeping is not without its trade‑offs: rising honeybee densities may compete with wild pollinators for scarce floral resources in densely built environments (McInnis, Normandin, & Ziter, 2023). Policymakers must therefore balance the symbolic appeal of artisanal honey with empirical assessments of ecosystem health—designing regulations that support both managed and native bee populations in the heterogeneous mosaic of cityscapes (Remmers et al., 2024).
In Tokyo’s Marunouchi district, urban apiaries described by Fiona Wilson demonstrate how biophilic design principles can foster social cohesion. The Marunouchi Honey Project—overseen by the Ginza Mitsubachi Project—leverages “pollen-rich grounds” near the Imperial Palace to bolster biodiversity (Wilson, 2025, p. 6) . This practice resonates with Timothy Beatley’s advocacy for “green urbanism,” illustrating Pirenne’s insight that cities “are ecosystems as well as economies” (Beatley, 2011; Pirenne, 1956).
Society and Environment: Urban Renewal and Resilience
“The Seine’s reopening marks a watershed moment for Paris’s civic renewal” details Paris’s effort to reclaim the Seine for swimming, a triumph of urban policy under Mayor Anne Hidalgo. Culturally, it reimagines Paris as a living, accessible city, countering its tourist-heavy image. Economically, the €1.4 billion investment promises long-term benefits in tourism and public health (Bouvier, 2025). Socially, it fosters community amid climate challenges, though capacity limits highlight equity issues. Policy-wise, it aligns with Hidalgo’s eco-urbanism, extending cycle lanes and car bans.
Jane Jacobs’ The Death and Life of Great American Cities (1961) celebrates such revitalization: “Cities have the capability of providing something for everybody, only because, and only when, they are created by everybody” (Jacobs, 1961, p. 238). Ecologically, it ties to Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring (1962), urging harmony with nature: “The control of nature is a phrase conceived in arrogance” (Carson, 1962, p. 297). In literature, Victor Hugo’s Les Misérables (1862) evokes the Seine as Paris’s lifeblood: “The sewer is the conscience of the city” (Hugo, 1862/1992, p. 1059)—its cleansing is a moral act. Philosophically, Michel Foucault’s Discipline and Punish (1975) might see this as power over public space, yet here it empowers rather than confines.
Urban and Environmental Adaptation
The reopening of the Seine for swimming in Paris and Tokyo’s urban beekeeping initiative mark significant urban responses to environmental challenges. Paris’s initiative, championed by Mayor Anne Hidalgo, embodies Henri Lefebvre’s “right to the city,” where urban spaces are reclaimed for public use (Lefebvre, 1968/1996). Cleaning the Seine, a €1.4 billion endeavor, reflects policy-driven adaptation to climate change, aligning with the World Bank’s call for cities to integrate environmental planning (World Bank, 2015). Tokyo’s Marunouchi Honey Project, fostering biodiversity atop skyscrapers, exemplifies community resilience, a concept explored in Resilient Cities, which argues that urban areas must adapt to ecological loss (Newman et al., 2009).
Culturally, these efforts signify a return to nature within urbanity, reminiscent of Thoreau’s Walden, where he sought harmony with the environment amid societal change (Thoreau, 1854/2004). Economically, they enhance livability, attracting residents and tourists, while socially, they build community—whether through shared swims or collective beekeeping. The sky gardens in Singapore and Milan further this narrative, mitigating urban heat islands and offering spaces of belonging, as Yi-Fu Tuan describes in Space and Place: “Place is security, space is freedom” (Tuan, 1977, p. 3). […]
References
[Supporters can find the full version of the article and the bibliographical information at this link: https://ko-fi.com/post/Signals-from-a-World-in-Flux-The-Politics-of-Emot-E1E41I16H3.]
[Written, Researched, and Edited by Pablo Markin. Some parts of the text have been produced with the aid of ChatGPT, OpenAI, Grok, X Corp, and Gemini, Google, Alphabet, tools (July 14, 2025). The featured image has been generated in Canva (July 14, 2025).]
[Support the Open Access Blogs: https://ko-fi.com/theopenaccessblogs/tip.]
OpenEdition suggests that you cite this post as follows:
Pablo Markin (July 14, 2025). Signals from a World in Flux: The Politics of Emotion, the Greening of the City, and the Performance of Identity. Open Access Blog.